SAG Awards 2011 Red Carpet Risks: Did They Work?

So I mentioned in my post below that the 2011 SAG Awards red carpet threw up a number of surprises that made for interesting water cooler debate in the fashion office. Some of them worked - Helena Bonham Carter in Marc Jacobs being the most exciting of these. And some didn't. Someone has got to have a word with the lovely Nicole Kidman about proper use of jewels. Please.
But have a look at these attempts that split opinion:
The delightful and brilliant Tina Fey did not wear black. Did it work? Oh yes it did. It looked fresh and fun and classy. I personally missed her authentic signature in the look - she looks a smidge too much like someone styled her - but it was a lovely change and she looked beautiful.
Claire Danes took a long walk far from her usual 'austere' simplicity style. Not only did the clean lines give way to a bit of flounce, but she was one of the few who embraced pattern in this Louis Vuitton frock. Did it work? Well yes it did, on balance. The dress looked good. She looked younger, vibrant and more modern. I think I might have chopped that belt off at the buckle. Maybe lost the buckle entirely as well. Then it would have been delightful.
And finally, the hilarious and charming Julie Bowen of Modern Family wore a jumpsuit. With a plunging neck. A case of just because you can, doesn't mean you should, per chance? I mean she looked awesome. Wow. But for the red carpet? Even for the SAG awards? Maybe not. A risk too far I think. Having said that, keep your eyes on O Magazine as we have a brilliant interview with Julie coming up in the April issue. It is actually possible to love her more than you already do. Fact.